Louisiana’s Auto Insurance Crisis and Gov. Jeff Landry’s Legislative Agenda 2025

Louisiana has some of the highest auto insurance rates in the country. This ongoing problem impacts many drivers and businesses statewide. For years, various lawmakers and state officials have attempted to address this crisis with little success. Governor Jeff Landry has recently shared a new plan. He believes this plan will lower auto insurance rates in Louisiana. His proposals target trial lawyers and insurance companies. They aim to change the legal environment that has raised costs for drivers.

Landry’s plan aims to:

• Make insurance pricing clearer
• Reduce excessive personal injury lawsuits
• Increase accountability for insurance providers and legal practices

In this article, we’ll look closer at Governor Landry’s proposals. We’ll explore their impact on Louisiana’s auto insurance market. Plus, we’ll share key data and real examples of the challenges residents face with car insurance.

The State of Auto Insurance in Louisiana: A Longstanding Problem

Louisiana has long been plagued by some of the highest auto insurance premiums in the United States. Recent data from the Insurance Information Institute shows that Louisiana has the second highest average auto insurance premiums in the nation, just behind Florida. In 2022, the average auto insurance premium in Louisiana was $1,558. This is high for many residents. For comparison, New York’s average premium was $1,549.

Many factors drive up insurance costs in Louisiana. One key reason is the state’s special legal environment. The state’s tort system controls personal injury lawsuits. Many criticize it for favoring plaintiffs. This often results in high settlements and big payouts from insurance companies. Insurance companies often raise premiums for policyholders. They do this to cover the higher costs from legal battles.

Louisiana faces a high risk of natural disasters, especially hurricanes. This makes it tough for insurance companies to predict and manage risks. As a result, premiums rise even more. A big part of the blame goes to a long-standing issue: the state’s legal environment. This includes the aggressive tactics used by trial lawyers.

Governor Landry’s Legislative Agenda: A Balanced Approach

Governor Jeff Landry has shared a detailed plan. He thinks it will tackle the main reasons for high auto insurance costs in Louisiana. Unlike earlier plans that focused on one side, Landry’s plan seeks to regulate both trial lawyers and insurance companies. This approach aims for a fairer and clearer system.

1. Transparency in Insurance Rate Calculations

A key part of Landry’s agenda is a proposal. It would make insurance companies reveal how they set auto insurance rates. Insurance providers can keep their rate formulas secret. They label them as proprietary, treating them like trade secrets. Drivers and regulators lack transparency. This keeps them in the dark about what causes premium increases.

Landry says that if insurance companies share their rate algorithms, the state can make sure premiums are fair and not too high. He proposed that the state insurance commissioner review these formulas. This way, the commissioner can ensure the rates charged by insurers are not “excessive.” However, Landry has stopped short of saying whether these rate formulas should be made publicly accessible to all residents.

The goal here is to provide more clarity to consumers, who have long been frustrated by seemingly arbitrary rate hikes. If this proposal passes, it could change how insurance companies price policies. They may need to be more competitive with their rates.

2. Addressing Personal Injury Lawsuits

Another cornerstone of Governor Landry’s plan is to address the impact of personal injury lawsuits on auto insurance rates. Louisiana’s legal rules, especially the Housley presumption, are said to raise auto insurance costs. The Housley presumption, established in a 1991 Louisiana Supreme Court case, allows courts to assume that a plaintiff’s injuries resulted from an accident if they were in good health beforehand. Critics say this rule helps plaintiffs win lawsuits and get big settlements. This, in turn, raises insurance costs for everyone.

Landry wants to get rid of the Housley presumption. He believes it helps plaintiffs too much and leads to too many insurance claims. He also wants stricter rules for trial lawyers. He plans to limit their advertising. He claims this advertising has led to a culture of excessive lawsuits. Landry is frustrated with the constant ads from trial lawyers. He specifically mentions Morris Bart, a famous attorney in New Orleans. Bart’s ads are everywhere and symbolize Louisiana’s legal scene.

3. Regulation of Insurance Industry Practices

Landry’s agenda also seeks to reduce trial lawyers’ influence. It includes steps to regulate insurance company practices. One of his proposals is to require insurers to offer a 5% rate discount for commercial trucks that are equipped with dashboard cameras. This proposal is aimed at improving safety and reducing the number of claims resulting from accidents.

Landry also seeks to prohibit insurers from using a driver’s credit score as a factor in determining their rates. Some insurance companies face criticism for using credit scores to predict driving risk. Many believe this harms lower-income individuals with imperfect credit histories.

Real-Time Examples and Impact on Louisiana Drivers

To see how these proposals could affect Louisiana residents, let’s look at real examples. High auto insurance premiums have hit drivers in the state hard.

A small business owner in Baton Rouge runs a delivery service with several vehicles. Last year, she faced a nearly 30% increase in her insurance premium. The reason for the hike? The insurance company noted more accident claims in the area. However, the business owner had a spotless driving record, with no accidents or traffic violations. Governor Landry’s new legislation could help businesses like this one. It aims for clearer pricing and stronger protections against unfair rate increases.

Another example comes from a family in New Orleans who was forced to pay over $2,000 annually for auto insurance, despite having a safe driving record. The family felt frustrated. They did not understand why their premiums were so high. They believed they were being punished for things they couldn’t control, like the city’s high accident rate. The governor wants to make insurance pricing clearer. This could help the family understand how their rates are set.

Fun Fact: Louisiana’s Legal History and Its Impact on Insurance

Louisiana’s legal history is unique. It uses civil law, based on French and Spanish systems, not English common law. This system has created unique legal practices. One example is the Housley presumption used in personal injury lawsuits. Louisiana’s legal traditions have greatly influenced auto insurance today. This makes the system complex and frustrating for insurers and drivers alike.

Conclusion: A New Hope for Louisiana’s Auto Insurance Market

Governor Jeff Landry’s legislative plan could help fix Louisiana’s high auto insurance costs. The governor is targeting trial lawyers and insurance companies. This balanced approach to reform could give much-needed relief to drivers in the state. If these proposals pass, they could make the insurance market clearer. This may lower premiums for consumers and create a fairer legal environment.

The success of this agenda depends on lawmakers, insurance companies, and legal professionals working together. It remains to be seen whether these proposals will gain the necessary support to pass through the legislative process. Louisiana residents still deal with some of the highest auto insurance rates in the U.S. So, the need for real reform is more urgent than ever.

Luzern Risk, Captive Insurance Manager, Raises $12M in Series A Funding

FAQs